$200 budget · 168 picks · $2,396 spent · WR $1,005 · RB $961 · QB $211 · TE $180 · K $24 · DEF $15 · graded on paper and in the books
2023 Auction
Steals
points a game over the replacement at the position, ranked by price rank against margin rank
Dak Prescott9.4 a game over the 13th QB
Tua Tagovailoa5.7 a game over the 13th QB
Raheem Mostert7.1 a game over the 29th RB
Dallas Cowboys5.7 a game over the 13th DEF
T.J. Hockenson6.4 a game over the 13th TE
By points started
Busts
the two priciest buys per roster, ranked by points a game over the replacement
Nick Chubb9.2 a game under the 29th RB
Dameon Pierce6.4 a game under the 29th RB
Aaron Jones5.3 a game under the 29th RB
Justin Jefferson4.7 a game under the 33rd WR
Calvin Ridley0.9 a game under the 33rd WR
By points started
Top of the market
the eight priciest picks of the 168, a tie to the better season
RankPlayerPosPriceManagerPoints startedPointsValue rankValue
How the money went
against the average of eight auctions
This 2023 auction against the average of eight auctions on record, in dollars.
The auction rank
1
RyanC→A.688 all-play · paid like 2nd2
KappyC→A.682 all-play · paid like 6th3
GregB→B.623 all-play · paid like 4th4
CurtisF→B.610 all-play · paid like 1st5
AustinB→B.578 all-play · paid like 3rd6
David CheungF→C.468 all-play · paid like 7th7
David MF→C.455 all-play · paid like 11th8
AlexB→D.416 all-play · paid like 9th9
SobiB→D.409 all-play · paid like 8th10
StephanB→D.383 all-play · paid like 10th11
CalebB→F.344 all-play · paid like 12th11
MikayelC→F.344 all-play · paid like 5th
Ranked by the all-play rate of the drafted roster played optimally every week, byes and week 1 health in; on paper from Sleeper's week 1 projections under the league's scoring, in the books from what the players scored. Paid like: the roster's return per dollar against the board.
Every roster as bought
in all-play order · 14 buys each, by price
Points started1,876.1All-play9.6 wins · .478 on paper.688
TE
Travis EtienneRB$45JM
Joe MixonRB$39DS
Deebo SamuelWR$25JC
James ConnerRB$23TL
Trevor LawrenceQB$16ME
Mike EvansWR$15AC
Amari CooperWR$15TH
T.J. HockensonTE$8AG
Antonio GibsonRB$4JH
Jalin HyattWR$4OB
Odell BeckhamWR$3BB
Buffalo BillsDEF$1TB
Tyler BassK$1DA
De'Von AchaneRB$1
Points started1,561.8All-play9.5 wins · .514 on paper.682
DA
Davante AdamsWR$59JG
Jahmyr GibbsRB$29JH
Justin HerbertQB$23CK
Cooper KuppWR$22RS
Rhamondre StevensonRB$17JD
J.K. DobbinsRB$17EE
Evan EngramTE$8JS
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWR$8BR
Brian RobinsonRB$6DJ
Diontae JohnsonWR$6JJ
Jerry JeudyWR$2DC
Dallas CowboysDEF$1CD
Cameron DickerK$1TB
Tank BigsbyRB$1
Points started1,754.8All-play8.7 wins · .594 on paper.623
AB
A.J. BrownWR$55AJ
Aaron JonesRB$39JH
Jalen HurtsQB$37MA
Mark AndrewsTE$28GP
George PickensWR$12DS
D'Andre SwiftRB$8MP
Michael PittmanWR$6AD
AJ DillonRBK$4SM
Skyy MooreWR$4DS
Dalton SchultzTE$2JW
Jaylen WarrenRB$2BR
Baltimore RavensDEF$1DP
DeVante ParkerWR$1GG
Graham GanoK$1
Points started1,951.1All-play8.5 wins · .332 on paper.610
JA
Josh AllenQB$43BH
Breece HallRB$28MS
Miles SandersRB$19BA
Brandon AiyukWR$16JW
Jaylen WaddleWRK$16RW
Rachaad WhiteRB$15JD
Jahan DotsonWR$15IP
Isiah PachecoRB$14JT
Jonathan TaylorRB$9CW
Christian WatsonWR$9JF
Justin FieldsQB$7TH
Tyler HigbeeTE$5JE
Jake ElliottK$3WC
Washington CommandersDEF$1
Points started1,822.7All-play8.1 wins · .579 on paper.578
NC
Nick ChubbRB$64KW
Kenneth WalkerRB$30DM
DK MetcalfWR$29DM
DJ MooreWR$16DH
DeAndre HopkinsWR$16DG
Dallas GoedertTE$13JW
Javonte WilliamsRB$13GW
Garrett WilsonWRK$6ZC
Zach CharbonnetRB$4GD
Gabe DavisWR$3PE
Philadelphia EaglesDEF$2RP
Rashaad PennyRB$2DP
Dak PrescottQB$1EM
Evan McPhersonK$1
Points started1,548.0All-play6.6 wins · .283 on paper.468
BR
Bijan RobinsonRB$69DH
Derrick HenryRB$44CR
Calvin RidleyWR$40DS
DeVonta SmithWR$31BC
Brandin CooksWR$3DN
David NjokuTE$2NY
New York JetsDEF$2TB
Treylon BurksWR$2JW
Jameson WilliamsWR$2TT
Tua TagovailoaQB$1JF
Jerome FordRB$1GZ
Greg ZuerleinK$1RD
Romeo DoubsWR$1TB
Tyler BoydWR$1
Points started1,388.9All-play6.4 wins · .366 on paper.455
SD
Stefon DiggsWR$67SB
Saquon BarkleyRB$62JJ
Josh JacobsRB$22KA
Keenan AllenWR$19TM
Terry McLaurinWR$14CA
Cam AkersRB$7EE
Ezekiel ElliottRB$2JS
Jason SandersK$1CK
Cole KmetTE$1JJ
Jacksonville JaguarsDEF$1NC
Nico CollinsWR$1TA
Tyler AllgeierRB$1DJ
Daniel JonesQB$1PC
Parris CampbellWR$1
Points started1,487.8All-play5.8 wins · .606 on paper.416
TH
Tyreek HillWR$63AS
Amon-Ra St. BrownWR$50LJ
Lamar JacksonQB$29AM
Alexander MattisonRB$24DW
Darren WallerTE$21JW
Jamaal WilliamsRB$5ZM
Zack MossRB$1JM
Jake MoodyK$1CS
Courtland SuttonWR$1PS
Pittsburgh SteelersDEF$1JM
Jerick McKinnonRB$1DV
Deuce VaughnRB$1AL
Allen LazardWR$1DJ
Deon JacksonRB$1
Points started1,525.2All-play5.7 wins · .577 on paper.409
JJ
Justin JeffersonWR$61TK
Travis KelceTE$55TH
Tee HigginsWR$30AK
Alvin KamaraRB$19RM
Raheem MostertRB$7MT
Michael ThomasWR$6JT
Justin TuckerK$5DW
Deshaun WatsonQB$4ZF
Zay FlowersWR$2MB
Marquise BrownWR$2KM
Kendre MillerRB$2AT
Adam ThielenWR$1NE
New England PatriotsDEF$1DH
Damien HarrisRB$1
Points started1,403.6All-play5.4 wins · .587 on paper.383
AE
Austin EkelerRB$66CO
Chris OlaveWR$35PM
Patrick MahomesQB$29TL
Tyler LockettWR$15DM
David MontgomeryRB$11DC
Dalvin CookRB$10CK
Christian KirkWR$7MW
Mike WilliamsWR$7PF
Pat FreiermuthTE$6SP
Samaje PerineRB$6EM
Elijah MooreWR$3HB
Harrison ButkerK$2SF
San Francisco 49ersDEF$2JK
Joshua KelleyRB$1
Points started1,239.3All-play4.8 wins · .582 on paper.344
JC
Ja'Marr ChaseWR$72DP
Dameon PierceRB$31KP
Kyle PittsTE$17JB
Joe BurrowQB$16JC
James CookRB$14DL
Drake LondonWR$14CG
Chris GodwinWR$9KH
Khalil HerbertRB$8JA
Jordan AddisonWR$6YK
Younghoe KooK$6GS
Geno SmithQB$2EM
Elijah MitchellRB$2QJ
Quentin JohnstonWR$2NO
New Orleans SaintsDEF$1
Points started1,572.5All-play4.8 wins · .502 on paper.344
CL
CeeDee LambWR$69CM
Christian McCaffreyRB$66NH
Najee HarrisRB$24TP
Tony PollardRB$19GK
George KittleTE$13MD
Miami DolphinsDEF$1DK
Dalton KincaidTE$1DC
Daniel CarlsonK$1AR
Anthony RichardsonQB$1KT
Kadarius ToneyWR$1AR
Aaron RodgersQB$1RB
Rashod BatemanWR$1JM
Jonathan MingoWR$1JS
JuJu Smith-SchusterWR$1
Value is the points the player went on to start that season, for whoever started him, so a steal is a steal even if he was traded away. A member's first auction carries $10 extra, so a new manager's line reads against $210 rather than $200. The letter is the all-play rate of each roster as bought: its best legal lineup every regular-season week against every other roster on the board, byes out. On paper each pick scores his Sleeper week 1 projection under the league's scoring, with week 1 health in and each player available at his position's injury rate on record; Sleeper does not project the yardage and long-play bonuses, so every line runs a little under the book. A pick Sleeper did not project reads the trade model's week 1 line, and one with neither reads no projection. In the books each pick scores what he scored, wherever he was rostered. The price reading is separate: the roster's return a dollar against the board, as a rank. Margin is a pick's points a game over the replacement at his position: the best player the board would not start for anyone, or the next one past the starters where every drafted player starts. On paper the replacement is the 13th QB at 20.9, the 29th RB at 12.9, the 33rd WR at 12.8, the 13th TE at 7.8, the 13th K at 7.0, the 13th DEF at 6.3 a game. In the books the replacement is the 13th QB at 14.0, the 29th RB at 11.1, the 33rd WR at 13.7, the 13th TE at 8.8, the 13th K at 7.6, the 13th DEF at 7.8 a game.